Fractured Goodness: Aristotle's Response to Plato's Form of the Good
Christopher Shields, "Fractured Goodness: Aristotle's Response to Plato's Form of the Good"
English | ISBN: 0198915691 | 2024 | 304 pages | PDF | 3 MB
English | ISBN: 0198915691 | 2024 | 304 pages | PDF | 3 MB
Aristotle offers a searing rejection of Plato's commitment to a Form of the Good; core among his complaints is that goodness is not univocal, that is, that there is no single essence-specifying account of goodness covering all the many varieties of goodness there are. Aristotle's anti-Platonic arguments have been variously received: many of his readers regard them as wholly successful while many others maintain they are abject failures. This volume reconstructs and assesses these arguments afresh and asks a simple question: if they are sound, what is left for Aristotle? In particular, what principles does he have to vouchsafe the commensurability of the good things he himself regards as commensurable?